Bob Foltz who purchased 28 cars stated that about half of the trucks needed the
center hole reamed out slightly to fit firmly on the bolster. The trucks on the
repainted cars should be mineral brown, not black. Looking at the side view, on
the left side, there is a drop grab located by the "100000" in the capacity
rating. Charlie Slater pointed out that that grab should not be there. The interior
detail is there, but very lightly done - not very noticeable. Both Hendrickson
and Charlie Slater believe the color is too red and lacks the darker brown of
the Santa Fe. Further variations in brakes and lettering have been announced. Richard Hendrickson
had a full review in the 2007 vol. 3 issue of The Warbonnet. Andy Sperandeo
had a review in the October 2007 Model Railroader. Further tweaking information
was in Running Extra #40, 4th Quarter 2007.
2013 update: A 4th run is planned is sufficient pre-orders are received. That run, originally advertised for November, 2013, is now scheduled for April, 2014, if orders are received.
Several
articles have been written on the Caswell gondolas:
Santa Fe Open-Top Cars: Flat, Gondola and Hopper Cars 1902-1959 by Richard H. Hendrickson, 2009, Santa Fe Railway Historical & Modeling Society.
Santa Fe's
Caswell Composite Drop-Bottom Gondolas by Richard Hendrickson, Santa Fe
Modeler, 2nd Quarter 1991, page 12-20. (Includes plans)
Santa Fe's
Caswell Composite Drop-Bottom Gondolas by Richard Hendrickson, Santa Fe
Modeler, Jan-Feb. 1979, page 19-21. (Includes plans of -R)
More on
Caswell Cars by E. E. Ard, Santa Fe Modeler, Nov-Dec 1980, p. 4-5.
(includes photos of GA-5 ATSF 171317, 1952)
Caswell Variations, by
Richard Hendrickson and Byron S. Rose, Westerfield Models.
There
were a number of classes of Caswells. The GA-X were 900 cars built in 1913. The
GA-7's were 500 built in 1923. Santa Fe had over 8,600 of these cars of various
classes. Occhiello's Live List shows 186 of the GA-X in service in 1951 with only
4 remaining in 1956. Of the GA-7, 490 remained in 1951, 112 in 1956, and 19 in
1959. Other classes of Caswell's were also in service in the 50s. Many ended their
lives in MOW duty.
Hendrickson
reports that these cars saw very diverse use. "Large numbers were employed
in Colorado and New Mexico coal service and they were also loaded with other bulk
minerals - sand and gravel, ore, borates, limestone, and the like. They were used
in coak loading. Large quantities of sugar beets were transported during the summer
growing season and in timber country they carried wood chips and sawdust. In addition,
they carried any load that did not need weather protection." Many were used
in various kinds of company service hauling ballast rock, ties, and dirt. They
brought sand to company sand houses and removed locomotive ash and cinders. Company
cars in gray or silver add to the variety.
Charlie
Slater reports, "By far the most common brake arrangement of the caswell
gons in the 1940's and 1950's was to have AB brakes and the original vertical
hand brake, there aren't many photos of Caswells gons with an Ajax hand brake.
This combination Intermountain is not offering as yet. The only car I have seen
a picture of with an Ajax hand brake is a Ga-7 number 172477, I am sure there
were a few others but they seamed to escape the photographers."
Fred
Dabney added, "I was seeing them in passing trains and in the local (Las
Cruces, NM) yard far later-I'm tempted to say into the late 80's or beyond. The
wood sides had been replaced with steel sheet with the bracing remaining in a
few cases, and the floor hatches welded shut and the likages to the drop doors
removed."
The Santa Fe Society waycar book
shows WA-R, a Caswell with vertical staff brake in MOW paint, 1978, Rincon, NM.
Westerfield produced these cars in resin for
many years.
The Intermountain car is a welcome addition to many ATSF fleets. Intermountain
will have an opportunity to make several variations and paint schemes available.